Financial Decisions for Life After College
[formerly, Making Cent$ of Money - first started 2007-03-26]
Organized and presented by Professors Al Hibbard and Mark Mills
Key Concept for this session: Net Worth
If you will be graduating from college soon, getting a job, and entering the "real world", then there are some things you may wish to know about money. This seminar will discuss such issues as: health insurance and payroll; loans and mortgages; use of credit cards; and savings and investment. You will get some hands-on experience using various resources on the internet to help you better understand these issues. One site to visit that covers many of the topics discussed here is http://choosetosave.org. Here you will find many calculators, resources, and other valuable tips and links. Another general site, at Boston College, is worth visiting.
Concepts
Health Insurance and Paycheck Issues
Paycheck deductions
Checking/adjusting withholding (example)
Summary
Make your healthcare insurance decisions based on your personal health needs. If you are generally healthy and have a High Deductible Health Plan available, consider this cheaper option and be sure to also implement a Health Savings Account (HSA). Otherwise, consider the regular health plan that is available. Before you become a consumer of health care, review some of the terminology involved since the plans are not always intuitive. Regarding paycheck deductions, when you get your first check and payroll "stub" (now digital) that spells out the details, review each item so that you understand what is being taken out and for what reason. Be sure that you have some taken out for your 401(k)/403(b) contributions. Increase this contribution each year with your salary increase.
Loans and mortgages
- Large-ticket items
- Appreciating items versus depreciating items
Interest rates and terms of loans
- Mortgages
- Consumer loans (e.g., auto loans)
- Credit cards
- Fixed-rate mortgage vs. Adjustable rate mortgage (ARM): pros and cons (a
nice overview)
- No down-payment loans - be careful!
Loan payments
Additional expenses related to purchasing a home
- Closing costs ($900-$2,000)
- Discount points (a
nice overview;
another nice overview)
- 1 "point" = 1% of the loan amount
- Prepayment of interest, thereby lowering interest rate
of the loan
- Escrowing property tax and homeowner's insurance
- Initial purchases for "home"
Renting versus owning
Summary
As much as possible, try to borrow only for large items that increase in value over time (e.g., home, education, business) and not for items that decrease in value (e.g., car, boat). When you borrow money, the longer you borrow it and the higher the interest rate, the more you will spend on interest to cover your purchase (and this amount can sometimes become more than the original item). Thus, the maxim that while borrowing, time is not your friend. Buying a home is not always the "smart" choice; it depends on how long you plan to be there. Renting allows you to be flexibile for when you will be at a location for a short or unknown duration. Try to prepay loans whenever possible (generally, but not at the expense of not having an adequate emergency fund).
Credit Cards
- *Use but don't abuse. We recommend a practice of only charging on a credit care amounts for which you have cash-on-hand and then pay off the full amount every month (and not carry a balance).
- *Avoid annual fees, high interest rates, consider other fees and seek protection against fraud.
- FAQ for buying with credit and related advice
- Motley Fool on credit cards; Magnifymoney.com on credit cards
- Get Rich Slowly (book) on credit cards
- *It is important to know to watch and maintain a good credit score.
- *Troubles with abusing a credit card? Place it in a glass of water in the freezer.
Summary
Credit cards can be great if you use them correctly, or they can be a yoke around your neck if not. ONLY use a credit card if you have the cash (in hand - not enough to be coming next week). Avoid any credit card that requires an annual fee; there are plenty that do not. ALWAYS pay them off in full each month. Optionally, choose cards that give cash back for purchases (such as the basic citi bank card that gives 2% on every purchase).
Life Insurance
- It should really be called death insurance. If you buy a policy, it pays out only after your death.
- Generally, you should only buy life insurance if someone else depends on your income or possibly to pay for your funeral expenses. See here for more information.
- Roughly, there are two types of life insurance: term and whole. Term is the least expensive and 99% of the time it is the best. Whole life, or any other variation (apart from term), despite being claimed as an investment, is often one of the worst investments (with a few exceptions).
Summary
Always view life insurance as a safety net in case there is a death. In other words, only insure yourself or someone else if the loss of you or the other will financially impact your family either by income reduction or by now needing to hire more caregivers. Do NOT think of insurance as an investment (and so almost never buy whole life or similar variations); think of it as a pot of money to help those who are left behind and so (almost always) buy term life insurance. You do not need to insure your children. Once your children are on their own, if your own assets are sufficient, you may consider dropping or reducing your term life insurance.
Savings and investment
To get started, let's begin with an example to illustrate a few ideas.
WHAT? Looking ahead to future goals and planning for them
WHY?
- Save for emergency fund of 3-6 months (6-12 months if self-employed) of (net) income
- Save for specific projects or goals: Christmas gifts, next car, computer, appliance, vacation, remodeling, camera, hobby and so on
- Save to pay irregular bills: car license fee, annual life insurance, semi-annual or annual car/home insurance, and so on
- Save and invest for giving: churches, charitable organizations, children or siblings, needy
- Invest for retirement
WHERE? Vehicles that can be used
type |
time horizon |
risk tolerance |
range of return (average) |
Bank |
short (0-5 yrs) |
Conservative |
0.1% -- 3.8% (0.37%) |
CD |
short (0-5 yrs) |
Conservative |
0.2% -- 5.5% (1.5%) |
Money Market |
short (0-5 yrs) |
Conservative |
1.5% -- 6% (0.4%) |
Bond |
short (0-5 yrs) or mid-range (5-15 yrs) |
Moderately Conservative to Moderate |
1% -- 8% (3%) |
Stock |
mid-range (5-15 yrs) or long-term (10-40 yrs) |
Moderate, Moderately Aggressive, or Aggressive |
0% -- 10% (6%) |
real estate |
mid-range (5-15 yrs) or long-term (10-40 yrs) |
Moderate, Moderately Aggressive, or Aggressive |
0% -- 10% (depends on location) |
business |
mid-range (5-15 yrs) or long-term (10-40 yrs) |
Moderate, Moderately Aggressive, or Aggressive |
varies |
- *Instead of owning individual stocks, we would encourage either mutual funds or ETFs (Exchange Traded Funds) which can be diverse pools of bonds and/or stocks [shopping cart metaphor].
- Take a quiz on risk tolerance
- bonds are differentiated by ratings (and so may range from conservative to aggressive)
- stocks are differentiated by capitalization levels [small, mid, large] (and so may range from conservative to aggressive)
- stocks can be held in DRP accounts so that dividends compound by purchasing new stock
HOW?
- *payroll deduction -- [take advantage of any company match in a 401(k) or equivalent]
- *automatic electronic withdrawal - see Dollar Cost Averaging below
- *manually - save/invest irregular income such as a bonus, inheritance, income tax refund (whether large or not)
- interest versus dividends versus capital gains
- Taxable: any of the above in table
- *Pre-tax (until later) and post-tax: 401(k)/403(b), IRA (Roth or
traditional), HSA, traditional pension
- I strongly encourage you to consider the Vanguard Company for your mutual funds, IRA and other financial needs. I gain no benefit from this except very likely another satisfied customer. The focus is on inexpensive options with quality customer service.
Other considerations:
Summary
In contrast to what we said in the Loans section, when saving or investing, time is your friend. This is because over time the power of compounding works in your favor. (Roughly, if your return rate is r%, the your savings or investment will double in about 72/r years.) For saving and investing, it is very important to pay attention to how soon you anticipate spending the money (i.e., the time horizon). If you need it in less than 5 years, it is important to be in stable locations such as a bank, CD, or money market (or possibly short-term bonds); only if you don't think you need the money for 5 or more years should you invest in stocks. When you invest in stocks (sometimes called equities), generally do not buy individual stocks but rather an index mutual fund or ETF that covers a broad collection of stocks (to diversify) such as the S&P 500 or Total Stock Market. A good and easy way to get started is to have contributions automatically come out of your paycheck and/or your checking account. (See Dollar Cost Averaging link above.) Finally, the last important consideration is where (not which brokerage house but which type of accounts) you invest your money. There are essentially three choices: (a) Pre-tax (such as 401(k)/403(b) or traditional IRA) where the money goes into the account before the salary is taxed by the state and federal government (but you WILL pay the taxes eventually on the principal and all the growth); (b) Post-tax (such as a Roth 401(k)/403(b) or Roth IRA) where the money goes into the account after the state and federal taxes have already been paid, but it comes out tax-free, both the principal (any time) and the growth (after age 59.5); (c) Taxable brokerage account (sometimes called nonqualified account since it does not qualify for any tax breaks) where the money goes in after taxes have been paid and taxes are paid when it comes out (though it, or least a portion of it, at a lower tax rate) and yearly as earnings accrue. Which of the three is best? A balance of all three gives you the most flexibility since the first two can only have withdrawals (generally) after age 59 1/2 without significant penalty and taxes (on the pre-tax). Aim to build a three-legged stool employing all three types of accounts.
Conclusions
- Use pre-tax dollars from paycheck to pay for as much as possible: health insurance, life insurance, flexible spending, retirement
- When borrowing, keep the rate as low as possible and the length of the loan as short as possible
- If your company (or other party) will match your contribution to a 401(k) or related destination, contribute up to at least the free match.
- When saving for needs that may occur within a short time frame, place the money in a conservative instrument (money market or short-term bond fund). When saving/investing for retirement or other long-term goals, place the money in a more aggressive instruments (mutual funds of stocks).
- When saving/investing, the longer you can have the money set aside, it will be earning at better rates. Generally, the higher the rate of return, the actual return may be greater but so will the risk.
Action Steps for various stages in life
-
Getting a job
- sign up for direct deposit of paycheck - convenient, safe, and some banks reward you
- sign up for 401(k)/403(b) plan and contribute at least up to the match given by your company - invest in STOCKs since this will be for the long haul - work on increasing yearly your contribution (perhaps the amount of your yearly raise)
- consider carefully which health plan to choose, if you are given a choice, factoring in your health before you sign up for a high deductible or cafeteria plan
- do not sign up for optional life insurance if you need to pay it yourself unless you have dependents counting on your income
- consider also having a portion of your paycheck going automatically to a bank account for an emergency fund
-
Emergency Fund
- start creating a fund early with the goal to have 3-6 months of net income in a savings account and/or short-term bond fund
- look at https://www.magnifymoney.com for banks with higher rates of return
-
Housing arrangements
- if apartment - consider renters insurance if you have assets worth covering
- if buying a house
- don't buy more than you need or anticipate needing
- try to save for a serious down payment before taking out a mortgage
- consider a 15 or 20 year mortgage
- try to work on prepaying the principle
- look at https://www.sofi.com for guidance on mortgage rates
-
Student loans
- if the interest rate is over 3% or so, be sure to start working on reducing these asap
- set up automatic payments so that you know that the payment is made
- check with websites such as https://www.sofi.com for refinancing, if applicable (and get discount if referred from https://www.stackingbenjamins.com)
-
Credit/Debit cards
- don't use your credit card unless you have the cash to back it up
- see if you can elect to have email or text messages when your purchases/charges are above $5 (or some threshold) so that you don't have surprises
- sign up for auto-payments
- check sites such as https://www.magnifymoney.com for best rates for the type desired
- Learning about finances
- Podcasts to consider
- Books to consider
- Videos/movies to consider
-
Long-term savings
- use online banks with multiple accounts for various goals
- use auto-invest to automate your savings
- purchase taxable index mutual funds after you have maximized your 401(k)/403(b) and your IRA (either traditional or Roth
-
Retirement savings
- highly prioritize immediately contributing up to the level that your company will match your contributions in a 401(k)/403(b)
- increase your contributions on a yearly basis until have reached the maximum allowed
- consider some portion, if possible, into a Roth account
- start an individual IRA even if you have not maximized your 401(k)/403(b), especially if you will have better choices than at work
- maximize your yearly IRA contribution
- begin saving outside of tax-sheltered accounts into taxable accounts by purchasing a total stock market index mutual fund (such as at Vanguard.com)
Last updated: 2023-03-07